The Costs Behind A Migrant Crisis: Migrants Run Gauntlet On Guatemala-Mexico Border

By Lorne Matalon
June 08, 2016
Lorne Matalon
Alex Morales in a migrant shelter in Arriaga, Chiapas. To the right of the cross behind him is an image of slain Salvadoran Archbishop Óscar Romero. He advocated for the poor and marginalized. In 2015, Pope Francis beatified Romero.
Lorne Matalon
Many people make a living on the passage of migrants through southern Mexico. Money changers line both sides of the border at Talisman, Mexico-El Carmen, Guatemala.
Lorne Matalon
Lorne Matalon
A migrant boards a train in Veracruz in 2008. Today, under Plan Frontera Sur, Mexico's southern border plan, raids on cargo trains ferrying migrants North have translated into fewer migrants boarding trains from southern Mexico.
Lorne Matalon

ARRIAGA, Chiapas — The town of Arriaga in the southern Mexican state of Chiapas perfectly encapsulates how migration through Mexico has changed since 2014. Located three hours and 11 checkpoints north of the Guatemala border, it's a former hub of trains known collectively as La Bestia, or The Beast.

But now, the train only comes here to bring in work crews who are repairing the tracks. Migrants who once lined the tracks have been replaced by police and Mexican immigration agents. They circle the town in trucks after months of raids, pulling migrants off trains and erecting concrete walls with barbed wire near the tracks to prevent access.

Migrants still show up here though, albeit in far fewer numbers.

SEE MORE: Photo gallery on the migrant situation on Mexico's southern border

Today Arriaga is still a possible first or second stop on the trek North depending on the route followed from the Guatemalan border. Guatemala and El Salvador have consulates in Arriaga. But now, many migrants leave Arriaga on foot instead of on the train.

Alex Morales said he'd been deported from Boston to Guatemala recently after living for 20 years in New England. "It's very hostile and dangerous," he said inside the casa de migrantes, or the migrant shelter in Arriaga, referring to Mexico's pressure on the southern border. One lawyer with the attorney general's office of Oaxaca called it a "climate of legalized anarchy" in the South.

Morales was hunkered down in Arriaga after walking the better part of 200 miles inland over the course of two weeks to avoid checkpoints. He said he camped out at night not knowing whose land he might be on. The landscape here is littered with stories of abuse of migrants, not just by authorities but also by ordinary people. The checkpoints, mobile and fixed, are a major component of Mexico's border offensive. U.S. funds have paid for some of the checkpoints. Morales says they are working.

"It's hard for the immigrant people to cross Mexico. It’s no easy way," he said.

Starting in July 2014, Mexico sent immigration agents from other parts of Mexico to the south, raided trains and migrant hostels and set up more mobile checkpoints.

Police officer Gisella Claribel patrols the tracks in Arriaga, but she said the only migrants she looks for these days are those sleeping under decommissioned rail cars near the now-barely used station.

"A lot more checkpoints have been put in and around Arriaga," she said in Spanish. Beads of sweat poured down her face and she squinted in the harsh sunlight. A blanket of diesel fumes permeated the area around the tracks where repairs are taking place. She defended the campaign of raids on the trains, saying assaults and murder are commonplace on them.

"Mexico is concerned about migrants' welfare," she claimed.

The U.S. government is supporting Mexico's southern border operations with technology and training, part of an operation that Mexico says is establishing order. Others such as 22-year-old Salvadoran Miguel Angel Ochoa say it's more like chaos.

He was crouched under under a rail car after arriving in Arriaga and thinking he could take the train on his way north. He said he had been living under the rail car for three days and nights when we met him. Now he was plotting his next move from Arriaga after enduring what he described as a harrowing journey from the border with Guatemala to get here.

He described a situation that mirrored Morales' experience. But there was one difference. Ochoa said Mexican immigration agents aren't the problem, it's Mexican federal police.

"If you don't pay them, they hand you over to immigration," he alleged. He said he knew that because he didn’t pay on a previous attempt to traverse Mexico. He was arrested, deported to El Salvador and is now trying again, determined to get to the U.S. to be with his wife and U.S.-born daughter in Arkansas.

Some migrants are still managing to break through Mexico's border barricades.

"They’re taking the road network— buses, vehicles— and getting through [by] corruption, through bribery," said Adam Isacson, a researcher at the Washington Office on Latin America, a leading research group on security in this hemisphere and border policy.

SEE MORE: WOLA’S interactive map of border crossings, internal checkpoints and new migrant routes

In addition to individual migrants, Isacson said the human smuggling networks have also adjusted. "I think that (bribery) is the number one driver that is allowing smuggling networks to reassemble their roots as quickly and easily as they did. Corruption is rife and it is unpunished, and it is largely uninvestigated in the agencies we’re talking about. So it makes sense that they’d find a new accommodation reasonably quickly," he explained.

The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) has a field office near the Guatemalan border, in Tapachula, Chiapas. That office is dealing with streams of asylum seekers right now. In April 2016, UNHCR issued a call for urgent action to deal with growing numbers of Central Americans trying to gain asylum status.

Perrine Leclerc, who heads the UNHCR office in Tapachula said, "They walk for days, they walk during the night."

Mexico granted refugee status in approximately 21 percent of requests in 2014 and the first seven months of 2015.

"Our main concern is to make sure that those who are in need of international protection have access to the asylum system in Mexico," Leclerc continued. She said virtually all migrants express variations on the same theme: organized crime, poverty and weak social institutions. Migrants say these outweigh any risk implied by heading north. She believes the migrant trail today is frayed.

"It's more dangerous because people are more invisible. They are outside of the network, the humanitarian network. And it makes them much more vulnerable to extortion, to violence along the way," Leclerc said. According to Mexico's human rights commission, complaints of extortion and violence by immigration agents rose by 52 percent in year one of Programa Frontera Sur.

Behind Leclerc in a shielded room, migrants with bitter stories of life in their home countries— principally El Salvador, Guatemala and Honduras, called the northern triangle of Central America— were being interviewed by UNHCR staff working overtime to help guide migrants through Mexico's asylum process.

Mexican law says migrants can request asylum. And immigration agents are supposed to inform detained migrants about their right to pursue asylum status. But migrants interviewed for this story, aside from these ones being assisted by the UNHCR, said they were unaware that option existed.

The U.S hasn’t spent close to all the money it pledged in 2014 to help Mexico on its southern border. Some analysts suggest that's because the U.S. has to choose its partners within Mexican law enforcement very carefully.

Maureen Meyer is an analyst at the Washington Office on Latin America. She posited that Mexico is basically stopping migrants for the U.S.

“We have met with (Chiapas) state police who also talk about getting U.S. assistance," Meyer explained.

She said working with Mexican law enforcement implies inherent risk.

"If you have a country like Mexico that has a history of abuse against migrants and human rights violations, you’re certainly giving more opportunity for that to happen to migrants," by assisting law enforcement, she said.

Duncan Wood, director of the Mexico Institute at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars in Washington D.C., said that for the first time, Mexico is inching toward at least a semblance of order in the South. But he also expressed concerns.

“If Plan Frontera Sur is going to overcome the considerable public relations challenges that it faces, we actually have to provide proof that this is protecting Central American migrants," Wood said. "Not just turning them back at the border or when they get to certain interior points within Mexico."

In December 2015, U.S. Congress approved $750-million for social and economic development in Central America, more than doubling such assistance over the previous year. The rationale was that helping weak nations develop internally may be a better key to immigration control than more boots on the ground to detain them.

Read more from our five-part series: The Costs Behind a Migrant Crisis